HSENI Safety alert
Department: Product Safety
Bulletin number: PS1-2022
Issue date: 26th April 2022
Target audience: Providers of respiratory protective equipment (RPE) and those required to use tight fitting RPE at work
New research by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) in Great Britain has revealed that respirators/masks which rely on ear loops (including those provided with clips, ‘snuggers’ or other means of tightening the fit of the mask) to hold the respirator/mask in place, do not protect people adequately when used as tight fitting respiratory protective equipment (RPE).
Outline of the problem
HSENI has seen an increase in the variety of ear loop respirators/masks, which indicate they offer the protection provided by FFP2 (filtering facepiece respirators or disposable half mask respirators). These products rely on having a good seal with the wearer’s face. For the majority of workers who are required to wear tight fitting RPE in the workplace, this seal cannot be achieved with a respirator/mask relying on ear loops to hold it in place.
HSENI does not recommend using respirators/masks secured using ear loops as tight fitting RPE.
If the respirator/mask uses ear loops, in most cases, it is highly unlikely to provide the wearer with the right protection. This includes any respirators/masks which use clips, ‘snuggers’ or other means of tightening ear loops, even if they have CE or CE+UKNI marks.
Following publication of the previous Safety Alert KN95 Face Masks in June 2020, the NHS took early action to exclude ear loop respirators/masks from their supply chain due to concerns over their protection. As a result, respirators with a head harness will have been supplied and fit test completed with this style of respirator.
Surgical masks and other face coverings are not affected.
Do not confuse FFP2 masks/respirators with masks or fluid resistance surgical masks (FRSM), shown below, as FRSM’s are used for a different purpose and are not required to be tight fitting.
Face fit test
To provide adequate protection for individual wearers, all tight-fitting RPE should be fit tested by a competent assessor as part of the selection process. HSE research shows that in the majority of cases a face fit test was not passed for CE or CE+UKNI marked ear loop mask/respirators and only in a very few cases was a face fit test passed. Because of this, HSENI recommends that ear loop mask/respirators are not used as RPE in the workplace.
Dutyholders are asked to revisit their The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (Amendment) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2005 risk assessment and consider their RPE provision to ensure it is adequate, suitable for the user and the activity to be undertaken.
If you have identified that tight fitting RPE is required, you should note HSENI does not recommend using a mask/respirator which relies on ear loops to hold it in place.
- Guidance on RPE fit testing (www.hse.gov.uk)
- Selecting and managing the use of RPE (www.hse.gov.uk)
- RPE at work - a practical guide (www.hse.gov.uk)
Relevant legal documents
- The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (Amendment) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2005 on legislation.gov.uk
- Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 - Approved Code of Practice and Guidance (www.hse.gov.uk)
- Latest chemicals news for Northern Ireland - updated 2 February 2023 02 February 2023
- Multilateral Agreement M351: Exemption from appointing a safety adviser for consignors 23 January 2023
- Belfast animal feed manufacturer prosecuted after worker loses hand in unguarded machine 19 January 2023
- County Londonderry gas and heating company prosecuted for safety failings 17 January 2023